AI-Powered Estimate ReviewAccurate Estimates.
Faster Resolutions.
Quoto compares carrier and contractor estimates side by side — line by line — and clearly identifies every discrepancy, omission, and variance between the two. Designed to bring transparency and accuracy to the claims process for everyone involved.
See it in action
A real estimate comparison processed through Quoto — every line item reviewed, every variance clearly documented.
Estimate Comparison ReportPowered by Quoto AI
| # | Description | Carrier Qty | Carrier Total | Contractor Qty | Contractor Total | Variance | Status |
|---|
| Roof (6 items) |
| 1 | Tear off, haul and dispose of comp. shingles | 40.01 | $2,432.21 | 40.01 | $2,503.83 | +$71.62 | Inconsistency |
| 2 | Roofing felt - 15 lb. | 40.01 | $1,286.59 | 40.01 | $1,286.59 | — | Match |
| 3 | Asphalt starter - universal starter course | 151.33 | $282.04 | 151.33 | $282.04 | — | Match |
| 4 | Laminated - comp. shingle rfg. - w/out felt | 40.33 | $10,155.00 | 40.33 | $10,155.00 | — | Match |
| 5 | Hip / Ridge cap - Standard profile - composition shingles | 75.67 | $427.14 | 75.67 | $427.14 | — | Match |
| 6 | Roof vent - turtle type - Metal | 3 | $197.39 | 4 | $263.19 | +$65.80 | Inconsistency |
| Front Elevation (2 items) |
| 7 | R&R Gutter / downspout - aluminum - up to 5" | 20 | $200.31 | 20 | $200.31 | — | Match |
| 17 | R&R Wrap wood window frame & trim with aluminum sheet | — | — | 1 | $278.81 | +$278.81 | Missing |
| Right Elevation (2 items) |
| 8 | R&R Gutter / downspout - aluminum - up to 5" | 9 | $90.14 | 10 | $100.15 | +$10.01 | Inconsistency |
| 9 | R&R Wrap wood window frame & trim with aluminum sheet | 3 | $836.44 | 3 | $1,117.28 | +$280.84 | Inconsistency |
| Rear Elevation (2 items) |
| 10 | Window screen - rescreen, 10 - 16 SF | 1 | $46.39 | 1 | $46.39 | — | Match |
| 18 | R&R Fascia - metal - 8" | — | — | 10 | $80.08 | +$80.08 | Missing |
| Left Elevation (3 items) |
| 11 | R&R Gutter / downspout - aluminum - up to 5" | 10 | $100.15 | 20 | $200.31 | +$100.16 | Inconsistency |
| 19 | R&R House wrap (air/moisture barrier) | — | — | 1328.92 | $601.14 | +$601.14 | Missing |
| 20 | R&R Siding - vinyl | — | — | 1328.92 | $7,293.71 | +$7,293.71 | Missing |
| Labor Minimums Applied (2 items) |
| 13 | Gutter labor minimum | 1 | $120.52 | 1 | $67.17 | $-53.35 | Inconsistency |
| 14 | Window labor minimum | 1 | $169.58 | 1 | $169.58 | — | Match |
| Debris Removal (1 items) |
| 12 | Haul debris - per pickup truck load - including dump fees | 1 | $160.66 | 1 | $160.66 | — | Match |
| TOTAL GAP | +$8,782.17 | |
← scroll to explore →
One click to a professional supplement letter
Quoto turns your comparison results into a ready-to-send supplement request — formatted, accurate, and based entirely on the numbers.
Supplement Request LetterGenerated by Quoto AI
June 16, 2026
Claim Number: CLM-2024-087341
Insured: Robert & Linda Harmon
Property: 4821 Maplewood Drive, Columbus, OH 43215
RE: Supplement Request — Storm Damage Claim
I am writing on behalf of the insured to formally request a supplement to the above-referenced claim. After a thorough review of the carrier's estimate, we have identified several discrepancies and omitted line items that are necessary to restore the property to its pre-loss condition.
Pricing Discrepancies
- •
Tear off, haul and dispose of comp. shingles[Roof]+$71.62Carrier allowed $2,432.21; current market rate is $2,503.83.
- •
Roof vent - turtle type - Metal[Roof]+$65.80Carrier approved 3 units; site inspection confirms 4 units require replacement.
- •
R&R Gutter / downspout - aluminum - up to 5"[Right Elevation]+$10.01Carrier allowed 9 LF; field measurement confirms 10 LF affected.
- •
R&R Wrap wood window frame & trim with aluminum sheet[Right Elevation]+$280.84Carrier allowed $836.44; correct pricing per current Xactimate is $1,117.28.
- •
R&R Gutter / downspout - aluminum - up to 5"[Left Elevation]+$100.16Carrier approved 10 LF; field measurement confirms 20 LF affected.
Omitted Line Items
- •
R&R Wrap wood window frame & trim with aluminum sheet[Front Elevation]$278.81Omitted from carrier estimate. Storm damage to front elevation window trim was documented in inspection photos.
- •
R&R Fascia - metal - 8"[Rear Elevation]$80.08Omitted from carrier estimate. Rear fascia sustained direct storm damage and must be replaced.
- •
R&R House wrap (air/moisture barrier)[Left Elevation]$601.14Required whenever siding is removed to ensure proper moisture protection per building code.
- •
R&R Siding - vinyl[Left Elevation]$7,293.71Left elevation siding omitted despite documented storm damage. 1,328.92 SF requires full replacement.
Total Supplement Requested+$8,782.17
All work reflected in this supplement is necessary to restore the property to its pre-loss condition and complies with local building codes. Supporting documentation, including field measurements and inspection photos, is available upon request. Please review this supplement at your earliest convenience. We are happy to schedule a joint inspection if needed.
Respectfully,
James T. Caldwell
Caldwell Roofing & Restoration
Phone: (614) 555-0192
License #: OH-RC-48821